My Gift Hint mascotMy Gift Hint
All gift advice

Our House Is Full and My Kids Have Everything. What Do I Get Them?

The short answer

Let your kids choose their own gift hints, approve what fits your home, and pick gifts that get used up or remembered.

  • Consumables
  • Experiences
  • Upgrades
  • Their #1 pick
5 min read
Illustration for: Our House Is Full and My Kids Have Everything. What Do I Get Them?

I still want my kids to have the magic of unwrapping something on their birthday. But our toy boxes are already overflowing, and I genuinely don't know what to buy that won't just sit on the floor a day after the party. If that sounds like your house too, this one is for you.

"Our house is already full. What do I get them?"

With our first kid, we bought everything: the tracks, the blocks, the play kitchen. By the second, every cupboard was full of hand-me-downs. So when family asked, "What do they want for their birthday?", my mind went blank. I honestly didn't know what to say.

But my kids did. They always have an answer.

The shift: let the kids choose, you approve

Now I let my kids choose their own presents, and I approve them. Don't get me wrong — some of them don't get approved if they're not appropriate. But this is a big solution, and it works for us.

Kids change every year. They know exactly what they're into. So the guessing, the searching and the decision-making are handed over to them. Our job is just to approve the gifts we're happy to welcome into our home.

Infographic: 4 gifts when the toy box is already full — consumables, experiences, upgrades and their number one pick

4 gift ideas that don't add clutter

Here's what I approve, and what I suggest to family, when the toy box is already full.

1. Consumables: played with, loved, then gone

  • A little seed or plant-growing kit — mini sunflowers or kitchen herbs to check every morning together.
  • Washable window markers or sidewalk chalk — big creative fun that rinses off with water.
  • Natural sensory playdough or modelling clay — open-ended play for rainy afternoons.
  • Bath colour drops or fizzers — bath time becomes an event, then it's gone.
  • A baking kit or cookie cutters — an afternoon in the kitchen together.
  • Art supplies and craft kits — paints, paper and crayons that get used up.

2. Experiences: memories over stuff

I've seen moms ask again and again for experiences like swimming lessons, zoo or aquarium passes and cinema vouchers, because they're tired of plastic toys that are forgotten a day after they're opened. Typical prices run about US$15–$60 (AU$25–$90).

3. Upgrades: things they need anyway

The next-size scooter, next-size pyjamas or proper sports gear. Useful, but still exciting to unwrap.

4. Their #1 pick

The one thing they truly want. Because they chose it themselves, it gets played with for much longer than five minutes.

How it works in our family

My kids add their gift hints to their own list. I approve the ones that fit our home, and then I share one link with grandparents, aunties and friends. We always say there's no expectation or pressure for anyone to buy the exact things on the list. But for anyone who'd like a little gift hint, here's what our kids would really love and use. Family tap "I'll get this", so nothing gets doubled up, and the kids never see who's getting what.

A real My Gift Hint birthday list on a phone, showing approved gift hints with photos and prices

Less guessing, more gifts that get used

Less walking around shops. Less late-night scrolling. Less guessing, less decision-making, and no more wondering if the gift will survive past the unwrapping.

That's why I made My Gift Hint: the kids tell you what they're into, you approve what fits your home, and family know exactly what to get.

Let them choose. You approve.

Free to use. One list for their birthday that family can actually use.

Start Adding Gift Hints

— Mira G

Keep reading

How to Make a Birthday Wishlist Your Kid Actually Wants — step by step, with your kid in charge.

Too Many Toys at Christmas? How to Ask Family to Buy Less — kind scripts for grandparents.